I know a lot of people are averse to renting a car on vacation (it’s so nice to go places where you don’t need to hassle with one!), but alas, Hawaii is a destination where you really need to rent a car.

Hawaii is not an all-inclusive destination where you’ll arrive by shuttle and never leave your resort (I mean you could do that…but it’s pretty expensive just to get to Hawaii so most people want to actually see Hawaii. If you want a cheaper resort only vacation, just go to Mexico).

Do You Need a Rental Car in Hawaii?

The islands are pretty large so unless you’re just going a few miles, taking Ubers and Lyfts isn’t really feasible (you could be talking $100 one way to go to another part of the island and then not be able to get a ride back).

The only exception to this is on Oahu. If you’re staying in Waikiki and planning on mostly just exploring Honolulu and doing the beach, you could get away without a car. There’s also a pretty decent bus system on Oahu. But if you’re planning on leaving Waikiki to see the rest of the island, car is still the best way to go.

So even if you’re staying in a “resort bubble,” you’ll most definitely want a rental car for your stay.

Discount Hawaii Car Rentals

I always book through Discount Hawaii Car Rentals. They’re seriously the only company I ever use. They’ll give you the very best prices, you don’t have to reserve with a credit card or pay until you show up, you can cancel and re-book anytime if you find a better rate, and they usually have a special that adds additional drivers for no fee. It’s a no brainer. Click here to check rates for your trip.

Turo

I’ve started using Turo quite a bit when I travel other places because I love being able to pick out my specific car and not having to wait in a line to pick it up (I don’t find it to be any cheaper once you add the insurance though), but none of the airports in Hawaii let you pick up and drop off at the airport.

So if you do go the Turo route, plan on having to take an Uber/Lyft to and from the airport to your car. I think that’s a bit of a hassle especially on the Big Island and Kauai where things are a little slower and sleepier (especially early in the morning when most flights leave). And it adds a little layer of stress to me the morning of departure.

When to Book

Anyways, I would reserve your rental car as soon as you know your trip dates, but then keep monitoring it to see if you can find a better deal as the trip gets closer.

Rental cars are finite in Hawaii so don’t wait around too long to reserve one or you may end up having to rent a more expensive category than you need.